My ending should be your beginning.

BKS Iyengar

krabappelsmokingLast week, the 2009 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine went to Elizabeth H. Blackburn, Carol W. Greider and Jack W. Szostak. A friend of mine was the first postdoc of Greider’s first postdoc. When Greider won the Nobel Prize, it polished her academic pedigree. She’s now the “grandstudent” of a Nobel Prize winner.

This made me think about my “degrees of separation” from BKS Iyengar. My current main teacher regularly studies with Geeta, Prashant, and BKS Iyengar himself. Unless I immediately apply to study at RIMYI in Pune, I will never witness Mr Iyengar (who will turn 91 this December) with my own eyes.

But am I at least a grandstudent of Mr Iyengar?

Well, PhDs and postdocs are much rarer than yoga students. Landing a prestigious postdoctoral research position is extremely competitive, and the relationship between mentor and protege is direct and often intense. Such influential relationships can and do exist between yoga teachers and students, but nowadays, with crowded classes and traveling teachers, they are uncommon. If students pursue advanced studies with a selective teacher (who accepts a limited number of trainees), there’s more potential for a mentor-protege type of relationship.

Still, if any teacher-student relationship continues for five, 10, or 20 years, it does become significant. Students don’t flat-out ask, “Can I be your student?” but long relationships speak for themselves: if there’s no chemistry, no compatibility, people move on.

For any degree of “transmission” to occur between generations of teachers, there is much responsibility on teachers—and also on students. Attending class and doing your homework are givens. But the best students also benefit the teacher: they bring new ideas, they challenge the status quo, they push the teacher to clarify her own ideas, they energize the class. Heck, they might simply amuse the teacher with humor, wit, and cheer.

Being an engaged student takes work, but my teacher reminds us that we should take advantage of our teachers: ask questions, volunteer for class demos, eke the most out of that $15 or $20 class. “Squeeze your teachers,” she advises—and she got that advice from one of her own teachers.

To consider myself a grandstudent of BKS Iyengar would be a leap. The grandstudent of a Nobel Prize winner shouldn’t mention it if she’s lagged in her own achievements. That would be empty self-promotion. Similarly, a yoga student should not brag about her teachers and their lineages if she has not proven herself worthy.

For more, see my past post, “Naming names.”

6 thoughts on “Grandstudents

  1. love this post and what you say about a student’s responsibility….I teach privately to 2 women who have been with me since day 1 of my teaching, 8 years.

  2. many programs require six months of three-times-a-week classes i.e. tuesdays 5-9 and sat-sun 9-5. being a nurse whose 12 hour days,three times a week schedule is different every month, this is impossible for me…and let’s talk price…i was looking at deepak chopra’s teacher training which allows home study and occasional week long intensives…good. i calculated that this would run me over $8000. ouch…bad. i am looking at one in chicago that has intensives and home study and is reasonably priced.

  3. This whole thing is a huge point of contention with me. Don’t even get me started.
    After my grueling 5 years of teacher training, which came after 10 years of serious study with a senior Iyengar instructor did I even get my basic Level 1 certification. Then there are aerobics instructors who have NEVER taken a yoga class, thought it may be fun to be a yoga instructor, take a weekend course and then go teach somewhere! ridiculous and crazy dangerous. Yes, these studios offering tt are making money, but they are watering down the quality, and they are doing themselves harm by turning out more students than a given geographic area can handle. I have been to towns where there are more teachers than students! How does this benefit anyone?

  4. I love your site. Just found it and am happily surfing.

    I assure you, high quality yoga teacher programs for less than $2500 do exist. I’m about to teach one in Vancouver. It won’t be run of the mill, and will cover essentials of yoga.

    That said, Iyengar, which you study, is among the most challenging in the world. Standards are high, and you’re tested vigorously. Your bar is raised high.

    I love Iyengar yoga. Adore it and him. He’s the dude who brought alignment to yoga. But every form of yoga is beautiful. My training is a 200 hour 1 month full-on, full-time immersion. The students will be completely transformed and will have strong foundations.

    Of course I studied Iyengar for years, which helps a lot.

Please post a comment! (To comment without logging into Wordpress, omit your email address or enter a different one.)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s