Nagging Aches and Pains: An Introduction

When I first tried yoga two decades ago, I was coming off a back injury. Well, not an injury per se. Just inexplicable, transient discomfort in my lower back.

At work, sitting at my computer, I’d feel restless and just plain achy. My employer was very accommodating about ergonomics. My chair was well made and supportive—although I wondered if I should try a balance ball. My industrial-strength keyboard tray was infinitely adjustable. Although not debilitated, I was leery of prolonged sitting on long plane rides, in movie theaters, and especially at my workplace.

I mentioned predicament to my yoga classmate Peter. The next week, he handed me a slim paperback, Mind Over Back Pain, by John Sarno. “I’ve lent this book to so many people,” he said. “I keep buying more copies because sometimes I don’t get it back!”

Published in 1984, the book was already 15 years post publication, but it was new to me. Similar in size to Strunk and White’s The Elements of Style and it was likewise concise and informative. Sarno’s ideas weren’t generally accepted by his medical peers, but he got his MD from Columbia and practiced at NYU—legit enough for a read, I figured.

John Sarno’s Mind Over Back Pain

Sarno made an impression on me for two reasons: First, he pointed out that structural abnormalities don’t necessarily cause pain. The same condition—shown by x-ray or MRI—might be debilitating to one person and unremarkable to another.

Second, he proposed that bodily pain is often caused by emotional pain. When you’re anxious or angry, he hypothesized, your brain distracts you from these emotions by creating bodily pain—in your back, neck, shoulders, hips. His remedy: address your emotions, whether by journaling, confiding in a friend, seeing a therapist.

I found these points somehow reassuring. It was reassuring to think that bodily pain correlated with emotional pain because no emotion would last forever, right? (I was rather stressed at the time, at crossroads in my career and in a bad relationship. I also observed that my back pain was situational. At home I could sit—at my desk, at the dining table—with relative ease.)

There’s no big drama to relate. I can’t recall if I tried journaling ala Sarno. Whether from my newfound yoga or from facing my emotions or from the simple passage of time, my back discomfort resolved and never recurred.

Mind-Body Connection Now Mainstream

A few years later, I checked out one of Sarno’s subsequent books. I didn’t like it nearly as much. Sarno had expanded his hypotheses; he was now applying his mind-body connection to the gamut of illnesses—and attributing all of them to emotional state. He had gone overboard.

I more or less forgot about Sarno until last fall, when a New York Times article sparked my memory of Mind Over Back Pain. I had to laugh at the reporter’s “I swear I’m not woo-woo” disclaimer; I could relate. But, nowadays, no one disputes the mind-body connection in the experience of pain.

Pain is now recognized to be a complex phenomenon with wide-ranging causes. For an overview on current thinking about pain, here are three informative websites:

The Pain Brain This New York Times series comprises articles, including the one on Sarno linked earlier, on chronic pain. It’s a good introduction.

Mind Over Pain Paul Ingraham’s PainScience website is a favorite of mine. I like his thorough research, including citations, and his rational, skeptical perspective. He covers a range of conditions and treatments—and debunks some popular strategies that even I’ve considered via wishful thinking. Regarding Sarno in particular, Ingraham’s “A Cranky Review of Dr. John Sarno’s Books & Ideas” articulates my own reaction.

Living Well with Pain I stumbled on Tina Price’s impressive website detailing her own experience with debilitating sciatica and making sense of pain theories. I appreciate her honesty and her logical application of theory to personal experience.

“Tool Kit” To Address Pain

To address chronic pain, we must consider both physical and mental causes. Here’s my step-by-step approach:

Movement When in pain, people wonder if it’s safe to move. For non-acute pain, movement is generally beneficial. Not moving essentially causes bone loss and soft tissue (muscles, tendons, ligaments, cartilage) atrophy. That said, movement intensity must be adjusted to day-to-day circumstances.

Wide-ranging movement is ideal. Walking, running, swimming, and other repetitive aerobic exercise complement yoga and weight training. For me, yoga has been invaluable in keeping my body mobile in “all” directions. When I injured my right shoulder 15 years ago, physiotherapy was initially essential, but only with yoga did I restore full range of motion (beyond basic “reaching for the top shelf” mobility).

Posture Although poor posture doesn’t necessarily cause pain, ideal posture is nevertheless a worthy starting point. It’s important to work on posture while healthy and pain free. It’s difficult to align the body while injured. Yoga can be a practical starting point to improve posture—if the type of yoga emphasizes good alignment (e.g., Iyengar yoga) and if the teacher is knowledgeable. Practitioners must be wise enough to modify (or to forgo) poses potentially risky for their bodies.

It can be useful to study posture on its own. In California Jean Couch’s Balance Center and Esther Gokhale’s Gokhale Method focus on optimal spinal alignment—in standing, walking, sitting, lying down. I have Gokhale’s 8 Steps to a Pain-Free Back and, although she includes too many testimonials, her step-by-step instructions are clear and sensible. The photos alone—comparing posture in different cultures and eras—are revelatory.

Physiotherapy / Chiropractic If you see your doctor about back pain, chances are, they’ll recommend first seeing a physiotherapist. Unless you have an acute injury, most doctors lack enough time (and, sometimes, enough expertise) to manipulate your body or to recommend home exercises. Note: By “physiotherapy” I’m referring to various methods of bodywork. An equivalent professional might be a chiropractor or fitness trainer.

If I trust the person, it can make a difference just to get the green light to move or bear weight on the injured body part. Sometimes, just the confidence that I’m not exacerbating the injury can be enough to reduce pain.

Massage Not everyone likes massage (believe it or not). If you, like me, have high resting muscle tone, you might feel “tight.” I have functional flexibility, but my muscles, especially in my neck and upper back, often feel tense. While short of painful, this excess tension feels uncomfortable. Therefore, I love deep-tissue massage. Just the anticipation of a massage cheers me up!

Emotional Factors What about Sarno’s theory that most back pain is “in the mind,” never mind herniated discs and slouched posture? For chronic pain without apparent cause, Sarno’s theory is worth considering. His suggestions are simple and doable. Just write down those nagging thoughts in an emotional purge or confide in a friend—anything that forces you to address what’s on your mind.

Even if stress or anxiety isn’t the root cause of your pain, it probably exacerbates it. When I’m gloomy about one thing, everything is colored by that dark cloud. So, even if Sarno’s theory is not quite on point, I doubt that his advice can worsen your situation.

In my title, “an introduction” is meant to emphasize that chronic pain is a wide-ranging phenomenon, beyond the scope of this blog post*. If you’re in chronic pain, don’t assume direct cause and effect. A multipronged approach is probably best. Do yoga, improve your posture, consult a physiotherapist or chiropractor, get a massage—and, maybe, just maybe, deal with your emotions.

Images: Cats epitomize ease in movement, repose, and quiet contemplation. I never tire of watching the feline species. This is Tilly, a senior calico and purring machine who lives in Santa Cruz, California. I caught these moments in 2018 and in 2021.

*In case you’re wondering, yes, my title is a copycat of JD Salinger’s Seymour: An Introduction.

10 comments

  1. Hi Luci,
    Thanks for a very interesting blog post. I had chronic tension headaches for years, which I assumed were due to multiple whiplashes from car accidents. In 2019 I was intrigued by a course called “Freedom From Chronic Pain” that was offered through the Shift Network. It’s partially based on John Sarno’s work. I had tried so many approaches and practitioners, in addition to being a yoga teacher and teacher of Jean Couch’s Balance work. That helped me avoid back pain, improve my posture and release tension, but the tension headaches seemed unreachable.
    After taking only 5 of the 7 FFCP classes, I had a huge improvement in my tension headaches the next year. (I had a chart keeping track of how many I had, to see if anything made a difference.) Now they are basically gone. It’s a miracle. So, I can definitely say that the mind-body approach can make a huge difference, of course, in addition to yoga and healthy posture!
    Take care,
    Dana

    Like

    1. Dana, thanks for sharing your story, which is especially interesting due to your teacher training in yoga and in Jean Couch’s Balance work. How encouraging to hear that a “miracle” is possible. (Although we met ages ago at the Yoga Room in Berkeley, I remember that you’re also a trained flamenco dancer!)

      Like

  2. Aloha Luci,
    Yours is a very timely post as I seem to be surrounded by chronic, nagging pain. Not mine, but those of my family and friends. Mostly it stems from chronic, nagging bad habits. Repetition—like carrying a too-heavy purse on the same shoulder every day, or sitting at the wheel followed by sitting at a laptop every day—or just daily stress, anxiety, tension, depression or whatever bad mojo exists in their lives. But for some, like my girlfriend, it was caused by injury, a major car accident a year ago.

    Practicing yoga and Thai massage have taught me that the body and all of its bones, muscles, organs and nerves—and even the subtle body through emotions—definitely conspire to keep those aches and pains deep in ourselves. It might take a lifetime or at least a long time of bad physical and mental habits, or a traumatic event, to implant those aches and pains. But then it takes constant care to heal.

    Beyond yoga and massage, and all of your other suggestions, may I offer my personal prescription of wine, weed and dipping in any body of water for total relaxation? LOL. Mahalo, Keith

    Like

    1. Thanks for writing, Keith. My first yoga teacher once commented on how lucky she feels to have yoga, a place to go “on the mat.” We all must find our own such solace and personal little sanctuary, I suppose. Aloha!

      Like

  3. As a physician, I entirely agree that this is an area that is crying for help. In fact, as a pediatrician, I see the mind-body connection and negative cycles can begin at a young age. Many children who end up with anxiety as adults initially present with abdominal and other psychosomatic pain. The pain is real, but not caused by a physical (body/organ) disease. As adults we often learn to tolerate or blame pain on our deficiencies and are too busy to address what can be improved by simple changes in our day-to-day lifestyle. This post reminds to work on my own “aches and pains”– movement (and yoga) are key steps!!

    Like

    1. Thanks, Judi! You must recall my own bout with inexplicable pain in sixth grade, when I couldn’t bear weight on one leg. I was absent from school and even saw an orthopedist–and then the pain soon disappeared without a trace. A mystery, or maybe not?

      Like

  4. Thanks for this great article, Luci. There’s definitely a link between emotions and pain. Years ago, my labour pains were soothed by the constant support of loved ones. I wasn’t familiar with Sarno’s writing. Judith Herman writes well about trauma, as does Bessel Vander Kolk in his book The Body Keeps the Score. Bonnie Bainbridge Cohen has explored movement throughout the life cycle and studies movement patterns that cause restrictive movement and pain. Katy Bowman has an anti-furniture and barefoot philosophy that supports an ease in movement.

    In my nursing practice, I’ve worked with traumatized patients whose physical wounds began to heal when their addictions and emotional pain began to subside. It’s important to remember that for some traumatized people, emotional pain is extremely difficult to overcome. Poverty and adverse childhood experiences create stressors that lead to physical and emotional pain for too many. The political structures that we live in have a lot to answer for.

    Like

    1. Thanks for sharing your experiences, Susan, and for the additional sources. You’re right that healthcare professionals must consider a person’s life experience.

      Like

  5. Thanks for an interesting post, Luci. I’ve been a believer in the mind-body connection for a long time, and I’m grateful that I found Iyengar yoga almost forty years ago. My ageing body is holding up well, making me think,”Okay, this stuff actually works!” And I love the cat photos to complement the article. So “you” to notice what an animal can teach us!

    Like

    1. Wilda, longtime Iyengar yoga students indeed show the lifetime effects of the practice. And you could be Exhibit A! Thanks for appreciating Tilly. Animals can be the best “people” and, yes, teachers.

      Like

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: